The Psychology of Investing: Why Smart Money Makes Dumb Bets

The Billion-Dollar Mirage
What do a billion-dollar startup, a health tech unicorn, and a charming founder all have in common? A fatal flaw in human psychology that makes us believe in things we shouldn’t. In 2019, Adam Neumann secured $4.4 billion from SoftBank for WeWork, a company that promised to redefine the way we work. It wasn’t just a real estate play; it was a "physical social network." Investors, captivated by the story, didn’t notice the mountain of debt.
Fast-forward eighteen months. The company was worth nothing.
This wasn’t a freak accident. It’s human nature at its finest.
1. The Brain’s Betting Glitches
A. The Unicorn Effect
• The Reality: Only 0.1% of startups reach a $1B+ valuation.
• The Investor Fantasy: 92% of VCs think they’ll outperform the market.
The math doesn’t add up, but our brains don’t care. Why?
• Survivorship Bias: We remember the Airbnbs and forget the 10,000 failures.
• Narrative Addiction: A compelling story ("Uber for X") always wins over spreadsheets. It’s just easier to believe.
B. The Charisma Premium
Here’s something that might surprise you: Founders who are attractive and confident raise 35% more capital, even when their business metrics are worse. Investors aren’t betting on numbers—they’re betting on theatrics.
Think about it. How many times have you been swayed by a great pitch? We all fall for it.
2. When Data Loses to Dopamine
Case Study: Theranos (an idea for a revolutionary blood test with no foundation to stand on)
• What Happened: $9B valuation. Zero working tech.
• How It Worked:
1. Authority Bias: Larry Ellison and Henry Kissinger were backing it.
2. FOMO: Everyone’s in, how could I miss out?
3. Effort Justification: We’ve already poured $300M into this. It must work, right?
The Herd Playbook:
1. One big-name investor buys in →
2. Others pile in to avoid regret →
3. Reality gets priced out.
Result? 70% of unicorns from 2015-2020 are now worth less than their VC valuations.
3. How the 1% Think Differently
A. The Buffett Test
Warren Buffett’s first question when looking at a potential investment:
"How could this business fail?"
Most investors? They ask, "How could this make me rich?"
B. The Munger Checklist
Charlie Munger uses a set of mental models to decide whether to veto a bet.
• Patience: "Wait for the fat pitch."
• Inversion: "If I’m wrong, what would that look like?"
• Margin of Safety: "Is this stupidly cheap?"
C. The Stoic Edge
Top investors practice Amor Fati: the art of loving reality, even when it hurts.
Take Howard Marks during the 2008 crisis. While others panicked, Marks swooped in and bought distressed debt for pennies on the dollar, 10X’ing his money. You think he saw that coming? No. But he was prepared to embrace what came next.
4. How to Outsmart Yourself
For Investors:
• Pre-commit to rules: For example, "No Series B investments > $100M ARR."
• Weight your decisions: 70% data, 20% team, 10% gut.
• Hunt red flags: If a founder is obsessed with "growth at all costs," that’s a big red flag.
For Founders:
• Frame against baselines: “The average SaaS churn rate is 5%. We’re at 2%.”
• Show scars: “Here’s why we almost died in 2022.”
• Kill the hype: No more “Uber for X.” Let the unit economics do the talking.
Business Blind Spots
The corporate world isn’t immune to these biases:
• Entrepreneurs who think their startup will be the next unicorn, ignoring the fact that 90% fail in five years.
• Investors who are swayed by charisma, forgetting to consider the actual sector success rates.
• Sales teams who celebrate a 2% conversion rate, not realizing that the industry baseline is just 0.5%.
Without context, data deceives. Without awareness, decisions become reckless gambles.
The Bottom Line
Investing isn’t about predicting the future—it’s about predicting human behavior, starting with your own.
"The investor’s chief problem, even his worst enemy, is likely to be himself."
— Benjamin Graham
Ready to rethink your next big bet?
Don’t let your brain’s glitches control your investments. Join a community of savvy thinkers who challenge the status quo and make smarter, more calculated decisions. Subscribe now and get insider insights delivered straight to your inbox.
Let’s outsmart the herd, together. 💡